Discover how the ARGUS Alignment Method™ is revolutionizing telescope technology by enhancing precision and performance.
Can you provide an overview of Arizona Optical Metrology (AOM)?
Arizona Optical Metrology (AOM), based in Tucson, is a small business specializing in the production of custom measurement equipment for optical surfaces and systems. AOM’s innovative technology is centered around computer-generated holograms (CGHs), which create three-dimensional holographic standards capable of measuring nearly any surface or wavefront.
What challenges are involved in creating accurate holograms, and how do they contribute to measurements?
Creating accurate holograms involves three critical challenges. First is the design of the hologram’s pattern. Using standard lens design software alongside proprietary algorithms, AOM generates grating patterns that diffract light to achieve specific optical effects. These designs are translated into detailed graphics files compatible with semiconductor photolithography equipment.
The second challenge lies in manufacturing, where advanced semiconductor techniques are employed to "print" intricate patterns onto glass substrates with nanometer-level precision. This process requires close collaboration with foundries to optimize the equipment for light diffraction rather than electrical conduction. Finally, thorough verification ensures that each hologram meets the required standards.
Every CGH undergoes rigorous quality control checks at multiple stages of the photolithography process, and each is accompanied by a comprehensive QC report detailing its performance metrics. These holograms act as calibrated standards, enabling precise comparisons between the measured items and known references. When coupled with interferometers, CGHs can measure even complex shapes, such as freeform surfaces, expanding the scope of traditional optical metrology.
What is the ARGUS Alignment Method™, and how does it solve alignment challenges?
The ARGUS Alignment Method addresses the intricate challenges of aligning mirrors in optical systems like two-mirror telescopes. These telescopes often prioritize compact designs, which demand stringent tolerances for precise mirror alignment.
Misalignment can degrade image quality, and traditional alignment methods—involving multiple field-angle measurements, hardware reconfigurations, and complex calculations—are time-consuming and error-prone. ARGUS simplifies and accelerates this process by employing CGHs as alignment references.
By combining CGHs with interferometry, the ARGUS method eliminates the need for multiple hardware adjustments and provides direct, real-time feedback for each degree of freedom in the alignment process. This reduces computational complexity and minimizes the potential for errors, enabling faster and more accurate alignment.
image Credit: AOM - Arizona Optical Metrology
How does the ARGUS Alignment Method work?
At the core of the ARGUS method is the System Alignment Master (SAM), a CGH positioned on the telescope’s optical axis. When illuminated by an interferometer, the SAM generates wavefronts to align the CGH with the interferometer, measure the telescope’s wavefront on-axis, and determine the tilt of the secondary mirror.
Additional patterns on the SAM allow for wavefront measurements at various field points and alignment of another CGH, the Primary Alignment Hologram (PAH). The integration of SAM and PAH ensures independent wavefront signatures for monitoring and adjusting each optical component.
This setup minimizes hardware reconfigurations and streamlines the entire alignment process. The method also supports alignment verification across different field angles, ensuring comprehensive alignment in a single hardware configuration.
What are the main advantages of the ARGUS Alignment Method?
The ARGUS Alignment Method offers several key advantages. It dramatically reduces alignment time by eliminating the need for repetitive hardware configurations and intricate calculations. Its deterministic process isolates the degrees of freedom for each optical component, ensuring precise and efficient alignment.
In addition, the method supports multiple configurations without requiring extensive operator expertise, making it accessible even to non-specialists. ARGUS is also scalable, making it suitable for both unique telescope designs and large-scale production, where consistency and precision are critical.
The inclusion of multiple hologram patterns on a single CGH enables seamless transitions between different alignment tasks, further enhancing efficiency.
What are the limitations of the ARGUS Alignment Method?
The process works best when the System Alignment Master CGH is placed in a location where the different field angles for system alignment verification are sufficiently separated. Another limitation arises when aligning a very fast telescope with tight performance requirements.
In such cases, field angle verification measurements may become a necessary step in the alignment process. Although this adds a few additional steps to the system alignment process, it remains significantly more efficient than traditional methods.
Could you explain the ARGUS alignment process and its comparison to traditional methods?
The ARGUS alignment process begins with aligning the PAH to the interferometer, followed by attaching the SAM to the telescope’s optical bench. The primary mirror is then positioned and secured relative to the SAM. The interferometer is repositioned behind the SAM to facilitate further alignment steps.
Next, the secondary mirror is aligned using the SAM-generated wavefront, and an Autocollimating Flat (ACF) is introduced to refine the alignment by reflecting the system wavefront back through the telescope. Additional wavefronts designed into the SAM enable alignment verification across various field angles.
Compared to traditional methods, which involve sequential field-angle measurements and require highly skilled engineers, ARGUS simplifies the process, providing simultaneous feedback for all alignment degrees of freedom and significantly reducing errors and time requirements. This integration eliminates the need for physical movement of the interferometer, ensuring consistent results and reducing alignment time by up to 50% in some cases.
image Credit: AOM - Arizona Optical Metrology
Which applications benefit the most from the ARGUS Alignment Method?
The ARGUS Alignment Method is particularly beneficial for high-resolution earth imaging, free-space communications, and high-energy laser systems. Its efficiency and precision make it an ideal choice for production-scale projects, such as manufacturing tens or hundreds of identical telescopes.
The method ensures consistent quality and performance across all units, meeting the rigorous demands of these advanced applications. Moreover, ARGUS is well-suited for applications that require repeated production of high-performance optical systems, where maintaining tight tolerances is essential. By simplifying the alignment process, ARGUS reduces overall manufacturing costs and accelerates project timelines.
Why is field-point verification and the measurement of Linear Field-Dependent Astigmatism (LFDA) important?
High-quality imaging requires telescopes to maintain minimal wavefront aberrations across their entire field. Field-point verification and LFDA measurements are crucial for identifying and separating nominal field-dependent astigmatism from alignment-induced errors.
By incorporating multiple field-point measurements into the CGH design, the ARGUS method simplifies this analysis, ensuring optimal telescope performance and reliable verification of alignment across all field angles. For systems with tight performance requirements, this step provides additional confidence in the alignment state and guarantees that the telescope can meet its design specifications across all operational scenarios.
How is the ARGUS method customized for different projects, and how does AOM collaborate with clients?
Each telescope system has a unique optical prescription, and AOM customizes CGHs to address specific alignment sensitivities and production requirements. For high-volume projects, multiple CGHs can be produced at relatively low additional costs, enabling scalability without compromising precision.
Collaboration plays a critical role in project success. AOM works closely with clients during the design phase to optimize system performance budgets and alignment strategies.
By engaging early in the process, AOM helps clients avoid costly design pitfalls and ensures the implementation of the most efficient alignment approach. AOM also provides training and support to ensure clients can effectively implement the ARGUS method in their production environments.
What future developments are planned for the ARGUS Alignment Method?
Continuous innovation is at the heart of the ARGUS Alignment Method. Each new CGH design provides valuable insights, aligning with AOM’s philosophy that "Light works for us."
Recently, AOM developed a simplified alignment method tailored for smaller telescopes with apertures under six inches, further expanding the ARGUS method’s applicability and making it even more accessible for compact systems.
AOM is also exploring advanced applications of CGH technology to enhance alignment for more complex optical systems, including freeform optics and multi-mirror configurations, ensuring the ARGUS method remains at the forefront of optical metrology innovation.
About Cormic Merle
Cormic Merle began his career in optics over 30 years ago at the University of Rochester Laboratory for Laser Energetics. He was responsible for implementing upgrades and maintaining the Driver Line – the ~40-foot-long seed pulse amplifier system for the Omega Laser. From there, he went to work for Lucid Inc. designing spectrophotometers and colorimeters, where he was awarded several patents for his work.
In 2002, Cormic went to work for Kodak Commercial and Government Systems as an optical metrology engineer in Precision Optics. For the next 20 years, he developed optical test solutions for optical components and optical telescope assemblies. Noteworthy within this body of work were the Center of Curvature Optical Assembly, used to verify the performance of the James Webb Space Telescope at cryogenic temperatures, and the optical test of the secondary mirror for the Vera C. Rubin observatory. The Rubin secondary mirror is a 3.4 meter diameter convex asphere which required the development of new technological capabilities to accurately measure the surface figure and verify the prescription.
Most recently, Cormic launched the Rochester office of AOM - Arizona Optical Metrology and has been applying his metrology expertise to a broad variety of optical challenges for the benefit of AOM’s customers. In this role, he has worked with Jim Burge to develop AOM’s ARGUS telescope alignment method leveraging holograms to simplify the alignment process, and is continually working to improve the efficiency of asphere and freeform measurements.
This information has been sourced, reviewed and adapted from materials provided by AOM - Arizona Optical Metrology LLC.
For more information on this source, please visit AOM - Arizona Optical Metrology LLC.
Disclaimer: The views expressed here are those of the interviewee and do not necessarily represent the views of AZoM.com Limited (T/A) AZoNetwork, the owner and operator of this website. This disclaimer forms part of the Terms and Conditions of use of this website.